Geo News rapped by Ofcom over “violent” bulletin

Geo News has been rapped by Ofcom for a “violent” news piece it aired during a bulletin on 28th July 2016 at 11:00.
Ofcom identified a news report broadcast on the channel about what was described as a “torture cell” operating in the Punjab, and allegedly being run by politically influential individuals. The item included secretly filmed and poor quality footage of a man, naked from the waist up, being subjected to a violent beating in the “torture cell”.
Ofcom translated the material from Urdu to English and provided the Licensee with an opportunity to comment on the transcript. Geo TV did not provide any comments on its accuracy. The first broadcast of the footage was shown split screen as the presenter introduced the item as above. The repeated slaps and punches to the victim’s unclothed upper body could be heard throughout.
The same sequence was broadcast full screen and then returned to split screen and was shown eight times. As the footage of the beating was broadcast, scrolling text appeared over the images which read: “Geo News Exclusive” and the “Breaking News” caption appeared intermittently. Another caption also appeared which stated: “Dozens of secretly taken videos of a torture cell have come to light”.
Geo TV explained that Geo News is an Urdu language rolling news and current affairs channel with its primary operations based in Karachi in Pakistan. Accordingly, much of its content “goes live” with editorial and compliance staff reviewing the content “as it is sent to the output team.”
Geo TV stated that the news item arose following notification by a news correspondent in Punjab in Pakistan that a “torture cell” was being run allegedly by “a politically influential individual”. When the news reporter had contacted local police no action had been taken. Given this and “the high likelihood of further serious abuse of people”, the Licensee stressed that it was in the public interest “to promptly take the story on air so that the abuse was brought to the attention of the public/competent authorities in public offices so that they would be forced to take appropriate action”.
In the light of Ofcom’s contact with the Licensee in this case, Geo TV said it had issued guidance to its news team. It had advised that in addition to verbal and onscreen warnings such footage should either be blurred or still images used which are appropriate for broadcast before the watershed. The Licensee considered this would be sufficient “to mitigate risk in the future and evidences how seriously we take Ofcom’s investigation”.
Ofcom was very concerned that the Licensee considered the broadcast of this material to be acceptable before the watershed. This was in particular because material unsuitable for children and inappropriately scheduled was broadcast on the same news service and found to be in breach of Rule 1.3 and Rule 2.3 earlier this year.
.
After the previous breaches recorded in issue 299 of the Broadcast and On Demand Bulletin, Geo TV said it briefed its news teams on providing appropriate warnings before broadcasting news stories containing challenging material and gave Ofcom assurances that it had provided further training for its staff. We also noted that with regard to this latest case the Licensee accepted that it had made an error in not broadcasting the verbal warning before the footage was first broadcast, and that in addition to the verbal and on-screen warning it would, in future, use blurred footage or still images.
As Ofcom has previously advised, broadcasters that all the BBFC certification symbols are both registered and unregistered intellectual property rights of the BBFC and cannot be used unless under licence. These rights extend to similar looking symbols. Ofcom advises broadcasters not to use BBFC symbols or similar looking symbols without prior consultation with the BBFC. The misuse of a BBFC classification in a broadcast is likely to give rise to a legal claim by the BBFC against the licensee.
Ofcom is requesting that the Licensee attends a meeting to set out and reassure Ofcom of its compliance arrangements as soon as possible. In addition, Ofcom puts the Licensee on notice that it will monitor this service. If any similar compliance issues are identified, Ofcom will consider taking further regulatory action including the imposition of a statutory sanction.

